Poetry & Analysis
Selected Butterfly Poems
Animal PoemsThe Butterfly
The butterfly, an idle thing,
Nor honey makes, nor yet can sing,
As do the bee and bird;
Nor does it, like the prudent ant,
Lay up the grain for times of want,
A wise and cautious hoard.
My youth is but a summer’s day:
Then like the bee and ant I’ll lay
A store of learning by;
And though from flower to flower I rove,
My stock of wisdom I’ll improve,
Nor be a butterfly.
Overview Short Summary
Adelaide O’Keeffe’s “The Butterfly” uses the insect as a warning against idleness. The speaker chooses learning and wisdom instead of merely drifting from flower to flower.
Core Ideas Main Themes
- Education: The poem encourages storing wisdom while young.
- Idleness: The butterfly represents beauty without labor.
- Youth: The speaker compares youth to a short summer day.
Emotional Effect Tone and Mood
The tone is moral and instructive. The mood is practical rather than purely admiring.
Interpretation Animal Symbolism
The butterfly symbolizes attractive but careless living, while bee and ant represent industry and preparation.
Close Reading Stanza-by-Stanza Explanation
Stanza 1
The poem contrasts the butterfly with bee, bird, and ant, emphasizing what the butterfly does not produce.
Stanza 2
The speaker applies the lesson to youth and chooses wisdom over idleness.
Literary Technique Imagery and Personification
The poem uses images of honey, song, grain, summer day, flowers, and wisdom. Personification appears in the animal comparison, though the poem functions as a moral lesson.
Craft Literary Devices
- Contrast: Butterfly idleness contrasts with bee and ant industry.
- Metaphor: Youth is a summer day.
- Moral lesson: The poem urges education and preparation.
- Symbolism: The butterfly represents careless beauty.
Poetic Form Rhyme Scheme and Structure
The poem uses two sestets with a clear moral structure.
Excerpt from The Butterfly's Dream
A tulip, just opened, had offered to hold
A butterfly, gaudy and gay;
And, rocked in a cradle of crimson and gold,
The careless young slumberer lay.
For the butterfly slept, as such thoughtless ones will,
At ease, and reclining on flowers,
If ever they study, ‘t is how they may kill
The best of their mid-summer hours.
And the butterfly dreamed, as is often the case
With indolent lovers of change,
Who, keeping the body at ease in its place,
Give fancy permission to range.
He dreamed that he saw, what he could but despise,
The swarm from a neighbouring hive;
Which, having come out for their winter supplies,
Had made the whole garden alive.
Overview Short Summary
This excerpt from “The Butterfly’s Dream” presents a proud butterfly sleeping in a tulip while bees work around him.
Core Ideas Main Themes
- Dream and idleness: The butterfly sleeps through useful hours.
- Beauty and pride: The butterfly is “gaudy and gay.”
- Work versus leisure: Bees gathering winter supplies contrast with the butterfly’s ease.
Emotional Effect Tone and Mood
The tone is satirical and story-like. The mood is bright at first, then cautionary.
Interpretation Animal Symbolism
The butterfly symbolizes pride, idleness, and the danger of valuing appearance over preparation.
Close Reading Stanza-by-Stanza Explanation
Stanza 1
The butterfly sleeps in a tulip cradle of crimson and gold.
Stanza 2
The speaker comments that such thoughtless creatures waste summer hours.
Stanzas 3–4
The dream begins, and the butterfly sees the hardworking bees he despises.
Literary Technique Imagery and Personification
The excerpt uses floral and dream imagery: tulip, cradle, crimson and gold, summer hours, hive, and garden. Personification gives the butterfly pride and the bees purposeful labor.
Craft Literary Devices
- Personification: The butterfly dreams, despises, and judges.
- Contrast: Butterfly leisure contrasts with bee work.
- Imagery: The tulip cradle creates a vivid sleeping place.
- Satire: The poem criticizes vanity through insect behavior.
Poetic Form Rhyme Scheme and Structure
The excerpt uses rhymed quatrains and narrative movement.
Excerpt from The Empaled Butterfly
“Ho!” said a butterfly, “here am I,
Up in the air, who used to lie
Flat on the ground, for the passers by
To treat with utter neglect!
“That horrible night of the chrysalis,
That brought me at length to a day like this,
In the form of beauty—a state of bliss,
Was little enough to give
For freedom to range from bower to bower,
To flirt with the buds and flatter the flower,
And shine in the sunbeams hour by hour,
The envy of all that live.
“Many a one that has loathed the sight
Of the piteous worm, will take delight
In welcoming me, as I look so bright
In my new and beautiful dress.”
Overview Short Summary
This excerpt presents a butterfly boasting about its transformation from neglected worm to admired beauty.
Core Ideas Main Themes
- Transformation: The poem emphasizes the change from crawling worm to winged beauty.
- Vanity: The butterfly takes pride in its new form.
- Social perception: Others despise the worm but welcome the butterfly.
Emotional Effect Tone and Mood
The tone is boastful, dramatic, and cautionary. The mood is bright but morally uneasy.
Interpretation Animal Symbolism
The butterfly symbolizes visible beauty after transformation, but also the pride that can follow admiration.
Close Reading Stanza-by-Stanza Explanation
Opening Lines
The butterfly announces itself as a creature now high in the air after once lying neglected on the ground.
Middle Lines
The chrysalis is remembered as a terrible night that led to beauty, freedom, and sunlight.
Closing Lines
The butterfly recognizes that those who disliked the worm now admire the beautiful winged creature.
Literary Technique Imagery and Personification
The poem uses images of air, ground, chrysalis night, bower, buds, flowers, sunbeams, and beautiful dress. Personification gives the butterfly a proud speaking voice.
Craft Literary Devices
- Monologue: The butterfly speaks about itself.
- Contrast: Worm and butterfly are placed against each other.
- Metaphor: Wings become a “new and beautiful dress.”
- Irony: Admiration is shown to depend on outward appearance.
Poetic Form Rhyme Scheme and Structure
The excerpt uses rhymed stanzas with a dramatic speaking voice.
No Go
Said a simpering Butterfly, sipping a rose,
To a graceless Mosquito on grandpapa’s nose,
Whom she hoped to entrap,
“Pray come, Sir, and taste of this delicate stuff.”
“Thanks, Madam, I’m just now taking my snuff,”
Quoth the impudent chap.
Overview Short Summary
“No Go” is a comic miniature in which a butterfly invites a mosquito to share a rose, but the mosquito prefers its rude meal.
Core Ideas Main Themes
- Humor: The poem turns insect behavior into a comic exchange.
- Refinement versus rudeness: The butterfly’s rose contrasts with the mosquito’s impudence.
- Personality: Both insects are made into social characters.
Emotional Effect Tone and Mood
The tone is witty and playful. The mood is light and comic.
Interpretation Animal Symbolism
The butterfly symbolizes delicacy, manners, and floral sweetness in contrast with the mosquito’s graceless appetite.
Close Reading Stanza-by-Stanza Explanation
Single Stanza
The butterfly politely invites the mosquito to taste the rose, but the mosquito answers with comic impudence.
Literary Technique Imagery and Personification
The poem uses rose, nose, sipping, snuff, and social-dialogue imagery. Personification is central because both insects speak like people.
Craft Literary Devices
- Personification: The insects converse politely and rudely.
- Comic contrast: The rose contrasts with the nose.
- Rhyme: The short rhymed lines sharpen the joke.
- Dialogue: The poem is built as a quick exchange.
Poetic Form Rhyme Scheme and Structure
The poem is a short comic stanza with rhyme and punchline structure.
Butterfly
Butterfly, Butterfly, sipping the sand,
Have you forgotten the flowers of the land?
Or are you so sated with honey and dew
That sand-filtered water tastes better to you?
Overview Short Summary
John B. Tabb’s “Butterfly” asks why a butterfly is sipping sand instead of flowers, turning a tiny observation into a question of taste and desire.
Core Ideas Main Themes
- Nature observation: The poem watches an unexpected butterfly behavior.
- Flowers and thirst: Honey, dew, sand, and water shape the scene.
- Curiosity: The speaker wonders what the butterfly wants.
Emotional Effect Tone and Mood
The tone is curious and gentle. The mood is quiet because the poem focuses on one small action.
Interpretation Animal Symbolism
The butterfly symbolizes delicate appetite and the mystery of animal choice.
Close Reading Stanza-by-Stanza Explanation
Single Stanza
The speaker asks whether the butterfly has forgotten flowers or has become so full of sweetness that sand-filtered water now seems better.
Literary Technique Imagery and Personification
The poem uses images of sand, flowers, honey, dew, and water. Personification appears through the direct questions addressed to the butterfly.
Craft Literary Devices
- Apostrophe: The speaker addresses the butterfly directly.
- Rhetorical questions: The poem consists of curious questions.
- Contrast: Sand contrasts with flowers, honey, and dew.
- Conciseness: The poem captures a single natural moment.
Poetic Form Rhyme Scheme and Structure
The poem is a four-line lyric with a simple rhymed structure.
Continue Reading
Related Poems & Articles
More selected reading from Animal Poems.
